If you think that’s too much custard and too little cake, you’re wrong. That is the perfect custard cake according to my husband. In fact he made me promise that that would be the name of this recipe. There is custard cake and there is custard cake but there is only one perfect custard cake — the kind that has more custard than cake. If you want a little history to go with this recipe, read Speedy’s cooking instructions on how to make cassava cake with custard topping. That’s the reason why this custard cake is the way it is.
Surprisingly, Speedy was right. It is possible to have all that custard without the cake falling sideways when sliced. If the custard is firm enough, it won’t crack and separate from the bread.
The basis for this recipe is one I found in All Favorite Recipes. But because I wanted less bread and more custard, I had to reduce the amounts of sugar considerably. Otherwise, the baked cake would have been too sweet.
Note that only a sponge-type batter will work when making a custard cake. DO NOT be tempted to short cut the procedure by using commercial yellow cake mix or a recipe for butter-type yellow cake. Butter-type cake batter is too dense and it will sink into the custard. The result is that you won’t have separate custard and bread layers but a very dense cake with no real character.
For best results, all the ingredients, the eggs and milk in particular, must be at room temperature.
For the custard :
6 eggs (yolks and whites)
1 c. of sweetened condensed milk
1 c. of skim milk (the ready-to-drink kind)
1/4 c. of white sugar
1/4 tsp. of finely grated lemon rind
For the cake :
3 egg yolks
1/4 c. minus 1 tbsp. of white sugar
3/4 c. of cake flour
1/2 tsp. of baking powder
1/4 c. of skim milk
3 egg whites
1/4 c. minus 1 tbsp. of white sugar (no, this is not a typo — you need two measures of the same amount of sugar)
Place all the ingredients for the custard in a bowl.
Mix until the sugar is completely dissolved. Do not beat as you do not want air bubbles in the mixture.
Place a strainer (you can use a piece of muslin) over the baking pan and pour in the custard mixture.
Sift together the cake flour and baking powder.
Place the 1/4 c. minus 1 tbsp. of sugar and egg yolks in a bowl.
Beat until smooth and lemon colored.
Add the flour mixture and milk alternately, mixing after each addition.
After all the flour and milk have been added, mix until the batter is smooth.
In another bowl, beat the egg whites until foamy. Add the second 1/4 c. minus 1 tbsp. of sugar little by little while beating continuously. Continue beating until the egg white mixture is stiff (see step-by-step guide on stages of beating egg whites).
Now you mix the egg yolk and egg white mixtures together. Remember that the reason you beat the egg white to stiff peaks is to create all those tiny air bubbles. It is these bubbles that will give volume and the light texture to your cake. Work carefully so as not to break them.
Add half of the egg white mixture to the egg yolk mixture and, using a rubber scraper and the cut and fold technique, blend the two mixtures together. Remember to scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl.
Then, add this blended mixture to the remaining half of the egg white mixture, and continue cutting and folding until the mixture is well blended and the color is even. Again, remember to scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl. No streaks of white nor yellow should be visible.
Pour the cake batter over the custard. Unless you overworked the mixtures and the tiny bubble burst, the cake batter should float on the custard.
Using a spatula, smoothen the top of the batter carefully. It doesn’t have to be perfectly smooth. This is an upside-down cake and so the top becomes the bottom, and out of view, when you serve the cake. Just make sure that all the sides are sealed with the cake batter so that the custard does not boil over it during baking.
Place the cake pan in a larger pan half-filled with hot (not boiling) water. Bake in a preheated 350oF oven for 50 minutes to an hour. After 50 minutes, insert a toothpick at the center of the cake. If it comes out clean, the cake is done. If not, bake a few minutes longer, testing every five minutes or so.
That’s how the cake looks when it comes out of the oven. The top is nicely browned. It’s tempting to invert and serve the cake at this point — BUT DON’T! The custard is still soft and you’ll ruin the cake if you try and serve it at this stage. Cool the cake — COMPLETELY. Place it on the counter with a screen cover. After an hour or two, you can continue cooling it in the fridge if you’re really in a hurry to serve it.
When the cake has cooled, take a plate that can hold the cake and place it upside down on top of the baking pan. With one hand under the baking pan and the other hand on top of the plate, invert the cake onto the plate. I advise you to do this over the sink because there is always a chance that the caramel will spill.
So, there you have your custard cake. All you have to do is to slice it and serve. In case the layers of cake and custard aren’t too distinct in the photo above, see the one below.
In my husband’s definition — that’s the perfect custard cake.
P.S. The hands in the photos — mine in some, my daughter Alex’s in others. She and I baked the custard cake.